Dale Thomas
Cimarron Thomas, 12, resided in West Virginia but was victimized by McCartney from a location in Northern Ireland
WARNING: This article contains disturbing details related to severe child abuse, suicide, and explicit language.
Cimarron Thomas was 12 years old in 2018 when she tragically took her own life using her father’s firearm.
Hailing from West Virginia, USA, she enjoyed playing the violin, adored elephants, chatting with friends on Snapchat, and was eagerly anticipating her 13th birthday.
However, behind the facade, she was a victim of online sexual abuse and blackmail by a student from Northern Ireland, identified as the UK’s most notorious catfisher.
Alexander McCartney, 26, from outside Newry, County Armagh, was sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum of 20 years for the manslaughter of Cimarron and the exploitation of other young girls.
In a tragic twist of fate, Cimarron’s father, Ben, a US army veteran, also took his own life 18 months later, unaware of his daughter’s ordeal or the reason for her suicide.
Cimarron’s grandparents, Peggy and Dale Thomas, expressed their anguish in a victim impact statement presented in court.
“Our lives will never be the same,” they lamented.
“We missed out on witnessing her milestones like graduation, marriage, and motherhood.
“We have been robbed, and our lives have been irrevocably altered.”
Cimarron and Benjamin Thomas memorial page
Ben, Cimarron’s father, took his own life 18 months after her tragic demise. The family was unaware of her victimization by Alexander McCartney.
Cimarron Thomas resided with her parents and siblings in an ordinary American household.
However, in 2018, a predator infiltrated their lives, wreaking havoc.
Under a false identity, McCartney engaged with her online, showered her with compliments, and initiated grooming before coercing her into sending intimate photos.
During their initial interaction, he coerced her into providing explicit images for an hour and 45 minutes, threatening to disseminate them online if she refused.
Cimarron, traumatized but silent, returned to school without disclosing the abuse.
Cimarron and Benjamin Thomas memorial page
Cimarron Thomas had been eagerly anticipating her 13th birthday
McCartney persisted in pursuing Cimarron, contacting her again four days later using a different fake profile, insisting, “I want to play one more time.”
Despite her pleas and distress, he callously ordered her to involve her nine-year-old sister in a reprehensible act, which Cimarron vehemently rejected, stating she would rather end her own life.
McCartney then initiated a countdown, bidding her farewell.
Within minutes, Cimarron’s nine-year-old sister discovered her lifeless body, having shot herself with the family’s firearm.
She was rushed to the hospital but was pronounced dead.
Authorities released the distressing 911 call made by the family seeking help.
The 911 call reporting Cimarron Thomas’ self-inflicted gunshot wound
On that tragic day in May 2018, Cimarron’s younger sister discovered her lying motionless in her parents’ bedroom, a gun beside her.
Her family remained oblivious to the reasons behind her suicide and the ordeal she endured.
Her mother, Stephanie, later disclosed that Cimarron might have been grappling with her sexual identity. Eighteen months on, her father also succumbed to suicide.
Years later, the truth regarding Cimarron’s ordeal came to light.
Cimarron’s grandparents, Peggy and Dale, participated in a BBC documentary shedding light on McCartney’s crimes, reminiscing about their granddaughter while sharing their anguish.
They aspire that sharing their harrowing experience will prevent other families from enduring a similar tragedy.
Grandparents recount their grief following the abused girl’s suicide
Investigation reveals the truth behind the suicide
McCartney appeared in a Northern Ireland court in late July 2019.
Police suspect he targeted approximately 3,500 children across 64 devices from 2013 to 2019.
The court described the devastation caused by McCartney as “immeasurable,” emphasizing how he “degraded and humiliated” his victims for his own gratification.
While many of his victims remain unidentified, their lives have been forever altered.
Alexander McCartney was a computer science student at the time of his arrest
In April 2021, just prior to McCartney facing charges related to the case, investigators uncovered the truth about Cimarron’s fate.
In a legal precedent, he was charged with Cimarron’s manslaughter, to which he pleaded guilty.
McCartney eventually confessed to around 185 charges involving about 70 child victims, aged between 10 and 16.
The Public Prosecution Service in Northern Ireland presented these as sample charges to streamline the court proceedings.
The court heard testimonies of the lasting trauma inflicted by McCartney’s abuse; victims reported experiencing flashbacks, shame, alopecia, and trust issues.
Some girls described feeling paralyzed at any physical contact from men, believing their childhoods had been stolen, and grappling with suicidal ideation.
From Northern Ireland to New Zealand
McCartney’s heinous acts transcended borders.
BBC News NI interviewed a man from New Zealand, identified as Stephen (pseudonym), regarding the abuse endured by his daughters after McCartney befriended his eldest daughter, then 12, on Snapchat.
The daughter, referred to as Rebecca (pseudonym), believed she was conversing with another girl.
What initially seemed like a friendship for Rebecca evolved over time. Dale Thomas Luego McCartney le pidió a Rebecca una fotografía desnuda, la cual ella envió.
“Luego usó eso para manipularla y chantajearla para que enviara más fotos, que terminaron incluyendo a nuestra hija más joven, así como parte del chantaje”, dijo Stephen.
“Y luego, con el tiempo, a través de su lista de contactos en Snapchat, agregó también a la prima de Rebecca, que era mayor en ese momento, y luego intentó amenazarla con obtener más fotos.
“Afortunadamente, ella fue lo suficientemente madura e inteligente como para comunicarse con mi esposa, y luego fuimos directamente a la policía desde allí.”
Cómo un depredador de catfishing apuntó a hermanas en Nueva Zelanda
‘Se aprovechó de su inocencia’
Dijo que tan pronto como se envió la primera foto, McCartney tenía poder, agregando que Rebecca estaba “jugando bajo sus reglas”.
“Se aprovechó de su inocencia”, agregó.
El padre explicó que su hija menor, que es dos años más joven, no sabía lo que estaba sucediendo.
“Ella solo pensaba que eran dos hermanas jugando a disfrazarse y tomando fotos tontas, así que en realidad está completamente ajena a ello hasta el día de hoy.”
Stephen dijo que el comportamiento de McCartney ha tenido un “impacto profundo” en su hija mayor.
A principios de año, se fue a la universidad pero regresó a casa después de seis semanas.
“Creo que se perdió oportunidades debido a problemas de confianza. Es algo con lo que tendrá que lidiar para siempre”, dijo.
“Sabemos que está tomando medicación todo el tiempo, y los lugares oscuros a los que estoy seguro que su mente va cuando está sola.”
Stephen dijo que él y su esposa han quedado devastados por lo que les sucedió a sus hijos, pero hubo un rayo de esperanza en que pudieron desempeñar un “pequeño papel en llevarlo [McCartney] ante la justicia y prevenir más víctimas”.
La serie de tres partes, Depredador Adolescente / Asesino en Línea, que examina este caso con mayor detalle estará disponible en BBC iPlayer, BBC One NI y BBC Three en las próximas semanas.
Para obtener más información y apoyo para aquellos afectados por esta historia, pueden visitar la Línea de Acción de la BBC.
“