He has the ability to dictate the tempo of games and his passing range makes him a threat from deep. Guardiola has praised Gundogan’s versatility and intelligence in the past. But as a more attack-minded player, he does not provide the same physical presence or defensive cover as Rodri.
That could be a problem against the more physical sides in the Premier League. City’s next four games are against Southampton, Norwich, Watford and Aston Villa – teams that will look to press and disrupt their rhythm. Gundogan may be able to cope against them but the bigger tests lie ahead.
That said, Gundogan’s creativity from deep could also unlock defences that sit deep against City. He could be the solution in games where Guardiola’s side are expected to dominate possession but struggle to break down stubborn opponents.
It would be a risk to rely on Gundogan as the main holding midfielder for the rest of the season but as a temporary measure, it could work. The German international has the experience and quality to step up when needed.
Phil Foden
Phil Foden’s emergence as a central midfielder could also be crucial for City in Rodri’s absence. The 22-year-old has been used in a deeper role at times this season and has shown his ability to dictate play from midfield.
His close control, vision and passing range make him a natural fit for the midfield role. Foden’s energy and work rate also make him an effective presser, which could help City win the ball back quickly in dangerous areas.
Guardiola has praised Foden’s intelligence and understanding of the game. He has shown a maturity beyond his years and has the potential to become one of the best midfielders in the world.
City may have to rely on Foden more heavily in midfield in the coming weeks and months. With Kevin De Bruyne and Bernardo Silva also capable of playing deeper roles, Guardiola has options to cover for Rodri’s absence.
Foden’s versatility and quality make him a key player for City in their title challenge. If he can continue his impressive form in midfield, City will have a better chance of coping without Rodri.
His ability to play out from the back and his composure on the ball make him another option for Guardiola in the deep-lying midfield role. Stones has shown his versatility in the past, playing as a defensive midfielder for England on occasion.
His passing range and vision could be key in transitioning the team from defense to attack smoothly. Guardiola values players who are comfortable on the ball and Stones fits that profile perfectly.
Overall, Guardiola has a wealth of options to choose from in the deep-lying midfield role. Whether it’s Gundogan adapting to a new position, Lewis showcasing his intelligence, or Stones providing composure and passing ability, City have the flexibility to adjust to any situation. Guardiola’s tactical acumen and the players’ willingness to adapt make City a formidable force in midfield, no matter who is chosen to play in that role.